Knee VA disability:
instability, flexion and extension rated apart.
How VA rates knees: instability under DC 5257, limited flexion under DC 5260 and limited extension under DC 5261, plus knee replacement. Evidence and pitfalls.
By Subha, Public Benefits Writer · Criteria checked
GrantsHubUSA · Independent editorial guide
- Diagnostic code
- DC 5257, 5260, 5261
- Rating framework
- 38 CFR § 4.71a
- Key consideration
- Instability and range of motion
Overview
Three ways a knee can lose function under VA rules
VA can rate different knee problems under separate codes when they describe different losses: instability (DC 5257), limited bending or flexion (DC 5260), and limited straightening or extension (DC 5261).
Since 2021, instability ratings depend on the type of ligament injury and whether a provider prescribed a brace or an assistive device such as a cane.
Degrees of motion and the instability scale
Limited motion levels under DC 5260 and DC 5261.
| Rating | Criteria in brief |
|---|---|
| 0% | Flexion limited to 60 degrees, or extension limited to 5 degrees. |
| 10% | Flexion limited to 45 degrees, or extension limited to 10 degrees. |
| 20% | Flexion limited to 30 degrees, or extension limited to 15 degrees. |
| 30% | Flexion limited to 15 degrees, or extension limited to 20 degrees. |
| 40% | Extension limited to 30 degrees. |
| 50% | Extension limited to 45 degrees. |
Instability (DC 5257) is rated 10% for persistent instability from a sprain or ligament tear with no brace or assistive device prescribed, and 20% when a brace or assistive device is prescribed (the exact rule depends on the type of tear).
It is rated 30% for an unrepaired or failed repair of a complete ligament tear when both an assistive device and bracing are prescribed. After a knee replacement (DC 5055), VA assigns 100% for 4 months, then rates the residuals, with a 30% minimum for a total replacement.
Source: 38 CFR § 4.71a, DC 5257, 5260, 5261
These summaries are not the full legal criteria or a self-assessment tool.VA decides the rating from the evidence. Read the full regulation text at the source link.
Degrees on paper and the prescription behind the brace
- Flexion and extension in degreesDC 5260 and 5261 are written in degrees: flexion limited to 45 degrees is 10%, extension limited to 10 degrees is 10%. A note that only says 'decreased motion' gives a rater nothing to apply.
- The brace or cane prescriptionDC 5257 levels hinge on whether a medical provider prescribed a brace, an assistive device such as a cane, crutch or walker, or both. A store receipt is not the same as a prescription in your chart.
- Ligament and meniscus findingsMRI or surgical notes naming a sprain, partial tear, complete tear, repair or failed repair place the knee in the right DC 5257 row. Dislocated cartilage with frequent locking, pain and effusion is 20% under DC 5258.
- Operative reportsDates and what was repaired, removed or replaced. Symptomatic removal of semilunar cartilage is 10% under DC 5259, and a knee replacement is rated under DC 5055.
- Service records of the first injurySick call entries, physical profiles or injury reports from service that show when the knee was first hurt.
Measurements taken at a knee exam
- 1Flexion and extension are measured on separate scales, DC 5260 and DC 5261, and stability falls under a third code, DC 5257. Each is rated against its own criteria.
- 2Functional loss counts beyond the degrees. 38 CFR 4.45 lists more movement than normal from relaxation of ligaments, weakened movement, excess fatigability and incoordination among the factors examined for joints.
- 3For instability, the DC 5257 level turns on what a medical provider prescribed for walking: nothing, a brace or an assistive device such as a cane, or both. The criteria are written around that prescription.
- 4Kneecap instability has its own rows in DC 5257. A surgery that did not repair the quadriceps tendon, patella or patellar tendon, such as arthroscopy to remove loose bodies, does not count as surgical repair there.
Knee evidence that often goes missing
- Treating a store-bought brace as prescribedDC 5257 wording requires that a medical provider prescribes the brace or assistive device. If one was prescribed, the prescription needs to be in the medical record.
- Claiming 'knee pain' as one problemInstability, limited bending and limited straightening are separate codes. A claim that names only pain can leave giving way or trouble straightening the leg unexamined.
- Assuming a replacement resets the rating to zeroDC 5055 assigns 100% for 4 months after a knee replacement, then rates what remains. A total replacement never drops below 30%, and chronic severe painful motion or weakness is 60%.
What a brace, a torn meniscus or a new knee means for the rating
It can. For a sprain, incomplete tear or repaired complete tear with persistent instability, it is 10% with no prescribed brace or device and 20% when a provider prescribes a brace and/or assistive device. An unrepaired or failed complete tear reaches 30% with both.
Yes, when the evidence shows each. VA General Counsel opinions allow arthritis and DC 5257 instability to be rated separately, and allow both DC 5260 and DC 5261 ratings for the same knee. Counting one symptom twice is still barred.
DC 5055 gives 100% for 4 months after the implant, starting after the 1-month total rating under 38 CFR 4.30. Then chronic severe painful motion or weakness is 60%, and 30% is the minimum for a total replacement. Resurfacing has no minimum.
The meniscus is the semilunar cartilage. Dislocated cartilage with frequent locking, pain and effusion is 20% (DC 5258), and symptomatic removal is 10% (DC 5259). Ligament tears causing persistent instability fall under DC 5257 instead.
Painful motion counts. The rating schedule (38 CFR 4.59) says it intends to recognize actually painful, unstable or malaligned joints, due to healed injury, as entitled to at least the minimum compensable rating for the joint.
Sorting instability, flexion and extension into separate codes is work an accredited representative can do with you. VA says the services of an accredited VSO representative are always free, while accredited attorneys and claims agents can charge. VA's accredited representative page has the search tool.
Knee codes, GC opinions and rules referenced here
- 38 CFR 4.71a: knee and leg codes
- 38 CFR 4.59: Painful motion
- 38 CFR 4.40 and 4.45: functional loss and joints
- 38 CFR 4.14: Avoidance of pyramiding
- 38 CFR 3.310: Secondary service connection
- VAOPGCPREC 23-97: Multiple ratings for knee disability
- VAOPGCPREC 9-2004: Flexion and extension of the leg
- VA.gov: Get help from an accredited representative or VSO
This guide explains published information. It does not replace medical care or advice from an accredited claims professional.
Ready to file or appeal?
Explore more conditions, or use the VA pay calculator to plan ahead.
